Graphic Novel I've read recently...
"V For Vendetta" by Alan Moore
Naturally after watching the movie that adapted the graphic novel, I had to go ahead and read it. Looking forward to the book, I expected the movie to be different than the book, but I didn't realize at how much was changed for the film adaptation. There were literally tons and tons of story lines, characters, names, and plot details that were altered from the book. The story that Alan Moore wrote felt too overbloated with the multitude of characters and sub-plots, that it got too much for the length of the book and actually felt a bit too pretentious at times. It felt rushed in what he was trying to say, and it would have been better if he made the whole story longer than it is.
I suppose the one bias I have against the book is the character of Evey Hammond (played in the movie by Natalie Portman). I actually liked the character of Evey in the movie, compared to the book where I found her annoying and stupid. I couldn't feel any sympathy for her character at all, which I believe is an important feeling to have in order to care for the whole story. Not to be too obvious, but I much much prefer the movie version of Evey over the book's.
As for the character of V, he is definitely an interesting eccentric character, and is the best thing in the book. A terrorist that we can sympathize with, but at the same time also hate. He gets a little too poetic in his dialouge at times though, that it does get a little much to follow him. V is enigmatic as a character can be.
The artwork by David Lloyd was a bit too....muddy and dark for my taste. A lot of the times I didn't know what I was looking at. Artistic, sure, but I'd like to be able to easily see what's going on without making my eyes bleed from confusion. Not exactly that great in action sequences either, and his strength is simply on thematic mood. He and Alan Moore did a great job designing V though, making him a very iconic character.
In complete comparison of the book to the movie, I have to be honest in saying that I much much prefer the movie over the book. The "streamlined" version of the movie felt much more appropriate in execution, and in capturing the main theme of the book. I know, for you comic book fans, that's just plain blashpemy. But put it this way, I much prefer Alan Moore's work in "Watchmen" and "The Batman : The Killing Joke."
Recent Comments